The Origins of Life and Precambrian Evolution

The Origins of Life and Precambrian Evolution

The Origins of Life and Precambrian Evolution Chapter 16 1 Questions What was the first living thing? Where did it come from? What was the last common ancestor of todays organisms and when did it live?

What is the shape of the tree of life? How did the last common ancestors descendants evolve into todays organisms? 2 Cartoon of the tree of life (Fig. 16.1) 3 What is alive? Living things have:

the ability to replicate or reproduce, together with the ability to store and transmit heritable information to have a genotype the ability to express that information to have a phenotype the ability to evolve to make changes in the heritable material and to have those changes tested in order to distinguish valuable ones from detrimental ones 4 Molecules as living things

In principle, a molecule could be alive by our definition: If it had the ability to copy itself using raw materials in its environment, and if errors in copying led to differences in the speed of self-replication or in chemical stability In this case, the genotype is the chemical structure of the molecule, and the phenotype is the speed of selfreplication or stability of the molecule 5 Protein vs. nucleic acid

Proteins possess the enzymatic function that would presumably be necessary for a selfreplicating molecule but there is no evidence that proteins can propagate themselves Nucleic acids possess, in principle, the ability to direct their self-replication via complementary base-pairing but until about 20 years ago were not known to possess any enzymatic function 6 The RNA world hypothesis Catalytic RNA molecules were a transitional form

between non-living matter and the earliest cells In the early 1980s it was discovered independently by Sidney Altman and Thomas Cech that some RNA molecules had enzymatic activity specifically, they could form and break the phosphoester bonds that link adjacent nucleotides in nucleic acids ribozymes This enzymatic function would be essential if nucleic acids were the first self-replicating things 7

Ribozyme from Tetrahymena themophila: a selfsplicing intron between adjacent rRNA genes (Fig. 16.2 a) 8 The catalysis performed by the Tetrahymena

ribozyme in vitro (Fig. 16.2 b) 9 The case for an RNA-based system as an early life form Existence of catalytic RNA RNA is a core component of the apparatus for translating genetic information into proteins rRNA a component of ribosomes (probably the component that actually catalyzes

protein synthesis), and tRNA adapters also required for protein synthesis Ribonucleoside triphosphates (ATP, GTP) are the basic energy currency of all cells and are components of electron-transfer cofactors such as NAD (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide) and FAD (flavin adenine dinucleotide) 10 Can RNA evolve? experimental evolution of RNA (Beaudry and Joyce 1992)

Select for the ability of Tetrahymena ribozyme to catalye the cutting of a DNA oligonucleotide and attachment of a fragment to its 3 end 11

Test tube evolution of RNA (Beaudry and Joyce 1992) (Fig. 16.4) 12

Can RNA evolve? experimental evolution of RNA (Beaudry and Joyce 1992) Experiment was seeded with a large population of randomly mutated ribozymes After 10 generations the catalytic ability of the average RNA in the population had improved by a factor of 30 Most of the improvement in catalytic ability was attributable to mutations at 4 locations Many additional experiments with natural and synthetic RNA have produced ribozymes that can catalyze reactions such as phosphorylation, peptide bond formation, and carbon-carbon bond formation.

BUT, a crucial piece is missing from the experiment that we have just described selfreplication 13 Genotypic changes in an evolving RNA population (Beaudry and Joyce 1992) (Fig. 16.5b) 14 Toward self-replicating RNA molecules

So far, we do not have a self-replicating RNA molecule (or a self-replicating system of RNA molecules) If we can produce such a thing (perhaps by selective breeding experiments in the laboratory) then, by one definition at least, we will have succeeding in creating life (although obviously not complex cells) 15

Laboratory evolution of the ability of catalyze the joining of adjacent nucleotides (phosphoester bond) (Bartel and Szostak 1993) Variable population of synthetic RNA molecules selected for ability to catalyze joining of nucleotides This is not self-replication, but a necessary function of a self-replicating RNA molecule Experiment still depends on the use of replicating enzymes to reproduce the successful RNA molecules after each generation

16 Test-tube selection scheme for identifying ribozymes that can link nucleotides (Bartel and Szostak 1993) (Fig. 16.6 a,b) 17 Test-tube selection scheme for identifying ribozymes that can link nucleotides (Bartel and Szostak 1993) (Fig. 16.6 c,d) 18

Test-tube selection scheme for identifying ribozymes that can link nucleotides (Bartel and Szostak 1993) (Fig. 16.6 e) 19 Evolution of catalytic ability in a laboratory population of ribozymes (Bartel

and Szostak 1993) ( Fig. 16.7) 20 RNA world summary RNA molecules possess at least some of the necessary properties of living systems the sequence of nucleotides provides a heritable information storage mechanism (= genotype) Catalytic ability is a variable, heritable phenotype upon which

selection can act Natural or synthetic ribozymes possess a variety of enzymatic activities, including the ability to join nucleotides together to make short (40 - 50 bp) polynucleotide strands However, so far, no one has succeeded in producing an RNA molecule that can copy itself Even if that is achieved, it still leaves the question of how the first RNA molecules were made 21

Pre-biotic synthesis of organic molecules: the Miller Urey experiments (1953) Water vapor + methane + ammonia + hydrogen + electric spark = amino acids (glycine, alanine) Similar experiments by others have yielded other organic compounds, including nitrogenous bases (from ammonia and hydrogen cyanide) and ribose (from formaldehyde) 22

The Oparin Haldane model (Fig. 16.12): the prebiotic soup 23 Criticisms of Miller Urey and Oparin Haldane Earths early atmosphere may not have been composed of methane and ammonia, but rather carbon dioxide and nitrogen, which would not have been favorable for formation of the necessary organic molecules (although

aldehydes could be formed from carbon dioxide) Formation and stabilization of polymers of basic buiding blocks (such as amino acids) in the aqueous prebiotic soup also appears to present difficulties (mineral scaffolding?) Still a long way from biological polymers to cells 24 Extra-terrestrial origins? Meteorites are sources of amino acids, at least some of which survive impact

The Panspermia hypothesis Life originated elsewhere in the solar system and was carried here on meteorites that originated from other planets or moons, or possibly life originated outside the solar system McKay et al. (1996): meteroite from Mars contained globules of carbonate + magnetite, iron sulfide, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: and a suggestion of microfossils that resemble bacteria Many (most?) are not convinced that the Martian rock provides evidence of life the compounds that were present can also be formed by abiotic processes

In any event, the Panspermia hypotheis merely shifts the problem of the origin of life to somewhere else at some other time 25 When was life first present on Earth? Radiometric dating of meteorites suggests that the solar system, including Earth, is about 4.5 to 4.6 billion years old

Sedimentary rocks from Greenland, and dated at 3.7 billion years, contain microscopic graphite globules that have a 12C/13C isotopic ratio that is characteristic of molecules produced by biological processes This may be about the oldest evidence of life that we are likely to find, because conditions much before that might have been unsuitable for life, or would have obliterated earlier origins of life 26 The history of large impacts on Earth and Moon

(Sleep et al. 1989) (Fig. 16.11) Red boxes represent lunar impacts; blue boxes terrestrial impacts (some of which are hypothetical. Dashed line represents impact energy sufficient to vaporize the global ocean. A = Archaean spherule beds; V = Vredevort; S = Sudbury; M =

Manicougan; K/T = Cretaceous-Tertiary impact crater (Yucatan) 27 What was the most recent common ancestor of all extant organisms? Regardless of the origin of organic molecules, and whether or not an RNA world was an intermediate step in the evolution of life, the evidence that all present day life forms share a common ancestor is

compelling All life forms (except some viruses) use DNA and proteins, and all use them in the same way (same 20 amino acids, same genetic code) The oldest cellular fossils (which resemble bacteria) are 3.4 billion years old 28 The phylogeny of everything Carl Woese (and others) We need a highly conserved molecule that has

recognizable similarities across all life forms Small subunit ribosomal RNA all organisms have ribosomes all use ribosomes in the same way (translation) all ribosomes are composed of RNA + protein all ribosomes have similar structure, being composed of

small and large subunits 29 Small-subunit rRNA phylogeny (Woese 1996) (Fig. 16.18): Three-domain classification 30 The tree of life old style (Fig. 16.17): five-kingdom classification

31 Three-domain classification system: Bacteria, Archaea, Eucarya Archaea (archaebacteria) more closely related to eukaryotes than they are to true Bacteria Archaea composed of two (or three) kingdoms Protista must be abandoned as a kingdom (paraphyletic) or must include animals, plants, and fungi. Animals, plants, and fungi do appear as natural,

monophyletic groups (with removal of slime molds from fungi) 32 What was the most recent common ancestor like? Highly evolved and biologically sophisticated perhaps similar to modern bacteria All living organisms store genetic information as DNA and have similar transcription and translation machinery

DNA polymerases are relatively similar across domains All organisms have DNA-dependent RNA polymerases that show strong similarities across all domains 33 Different genes give different universal phylogenies 1 (Fig. 16.22 a,b) 34

Different genes give different universal phylogenies 2 (Fig. 16.22 c,d) 35 Horizontal gene transfer Inconsistencies among genes for the universal phylogeny have led to the suggestion that taxa have exchanged genes horizontally Bacteria are known to be able to take up DNA from their environment and to incorporate that

DNA into their genomes (transformation, etc.) 18% of E. coli genes estimated to have arrived by horizontal gene transfer in last 100 million years (Lawrence and Ochman 1998) 36 Evidence for horizontal gene transfer of the HMGCoA reductase gene into an archaean (Doolittle and Lodgson 1998) (Fig. 16.23) 37

The cenancestor was not a single species, but a community (Fig. 16.26) 38 The latest possible date for the root of the tree of life Oldest known probable eukaryotic fossils (algae) are 1.85 2.1 billion years old Fossil cyanobacteria also suggest that the root is

more than 2 billion years old The most recent date for the root of the tree of all living organisms is between 3.4 and 2 billion years ago 39 The origin of mitochondria and chloroplasts The mitochondria and chloroplasts of eukaryotic cell have their own genomes Analysis of small-subunit rRNA genes suggests

that both organelles are derived from bacteria which have become obligate endosymbionts 40 Placement of mitochondria and chloroplasts on the universal tree based on small-subunit rRNA genes (Giovannoni et al. 1988) (Fig. 16.30) 41

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Principles and Practices of Global Health Engagement

    Principles and Practices of Global Health Engagement

    Principles and Practices of Global Health Engagement. Dr. Charles Beadling, FAAFP, IDHA, DMCC . Col (ret), USAF,MC, [email protected]
  • Chapter 2 Chemical Basis of Life

    Chapter 2 Chemical Basis of Life

    Hole's Human Anatomy and Physiology 12th Edition Chapter 2, pp. 51-55 ... Atomic Number # protons each element has a unique atomic number will the number of protons in an atom also determine how many electrons there are in an...
  • Do Now: - Rcps

    Do Now: - Rcps

    Let's go over the Do Now. 1. Check all answers that are correct. ... Complete the OSMOSIS worksheet on your own quietly. Be sure to raise your hand if you have any questions! FACILITATED DIFFUSION. The movement of solute from...


    Citator umumnya berisi penjelasan tentang apakah suatu putusan pengadilan dikuatkan oleh putusan yang lain, putusan pengadilan yang lebih tinggi, atau apakah sebuah dalil dalam suatu putusan pengadilan telah diubah atau dikesampingkan oleh keputusan berikutnya ; BAHAN HUKUM DI USA digest,...
  • How can we stay safe in the lab? - Lower Dauphin School District

    How can we stay safe in the lab? - Lower Dauphin School District

    Top 10 Science Lab Safety Protocols. Lab Safety Rules. 1.) Always wear safety glasses when you are working with chemicals or something that may get into your eyes. 2.)Neverbegin an experiment without your teacher's permission.
  • ANIMAL KINGDOM - Mr. Harwood's Classroom

    ANIMAL KINGDOM - Mr. Harwood's Classroom

    Carnivore Omnivore Herbivore Animal Classification Worms, sponges, mollusks, insects Animal Classification - Symmetry Animals have symmetry Bilateral Radial Invertebrate Sub Kingdoms Phyla Include: Sponges Cnidarians Worms Phylum - Sponge Simplest form of animal Phylum Porifera Greek: "Pore Bearer" Don't move...
  • Lecture 4 - Numerical Errors

    Lecture 4 - Numerical Errors

    Inverse Power Method The inverse algorithm use the technique avoids calculating the inverse matrix and uses a LU decomposition to find the {x} vector. Example The matrix is defined as: Accelerated Power Method The Power method can be accelerated by...
  • ENTROPY Entropy change (S) A SPONTANEOUS PROCESS (e.g.

    ENTROPY Entropy change (S) A SPONTANEOUS PROCESS (e.g.

    A reaction that is exothermic will result in products that are more thermodynamically stable than the reactants. This is a driving force behind many reactions and causes them to be spontaneous (occur without any external influence).